Skip to main content

Why are Librarians so Defensive?

When I studied library science as my second course, I didn't know that part of the job  would be to defend the profession and my own professional status from derogatory remarks.

Common statements, even from acquaintances and family, include:

"Why would we require licensed librarians when there's an Online Public Access Catalog (OPAC) in the library?"

"Libraries are embracing digital formats. Librarians will become redundant as physical books fade into history."

"No one frequents libraries anymore."

"You possess a Master's degree/PhD, yet you work in a library?"

and my favorite, "You need a master's degree in library science/license/degree to shush people?"

If anyone says these things, the short and quick answer would be: librarians and libraries are still relevant and necessary in this day and age. 

Some colleagues might choose to sidestep these remarks or individuals who voice them. Occasionally, such dialogues escalate into heated confrontations, especially in online platforms. I don't. I know that librarians are needed, and no one can refute it.

The significance of librarianship has been under scrutiny for years, particularly in the wake of the information explosion brought about by the advent of the Internet. 

No wonder so few people want to be librarians. Even today, certain educational institutions lack a designated librarian despite having a library facility. Often, the responsibility of overseeing the library falls upon a teacher with a relatively lighter workload or an individual in close proximity to the library who can assist its users as needed. 

 It's not widely recognized that librarianship has evolved into a bona fide profession in the Philippines. A licensing examination exists for librarians, and passing it is far from an effortless endeavor. 

Routine tasks, such as maintaining a Library Accession Book, present genuine challenges. Consequently, contemporary librarians frequently find themselves compelled to defend their profession when confronted by individuals who seem to underestimate its value. 

Despite disparaging remarks about my vocation, personally, I relish engaging in conversations regarding the relevance of librarianship and am always ready to give my two cents.

Here are a few of my retorts intended to "defend" my profession and elucidate why librarians continue to be essential: 

"We're entrusted with the management of both archives and digital resources, overseeing their digitization and proficient organization." 

"The role of librarians becomes paramount during information crises. Their relevance emerges when there's a need to efficiently sort and retrieve information within any organizational setting." 

"Books represent curated repositories of knowledge, and no internet content can truly supplant their significance." 


Popular posts from this blog

Your City Needs Its Writers: 3 Steps to Improve the Writing Culture in Your City

There is a La Union Books and Arts Exhibit right now at the SM City La Union, and this got me thinking. Every city has its share of storytellers. Some write novels. Some write long social media captions that probably should have been novels. I personally think a city with no active writers feels a bit empty, like a place that only knows traffic and billboards but has no imagination. A writing culture is not optional. It is the difference between a town that thinks and a town that merely exists. If you want to encourage a writing culture where you live, start by following these 3 steps: Step 1: Make writers visible. Invite local authors to your library, schools, community centers, and yes even your neighborhood book clubs. In fact, book clubs are one of the easiest groups to involve, because they already read, already discuss stories, and usually already have snacks. A sponsored book club event featuring a hometown author can do more for visibility than a month of posters. And honestly,...

Better Library Shelfing by Colocation: Grouping Similar Items

As librarians, we've all faced the challenge of making the most of our shelf space. It's like a puzzle, figuring out where each book belongs so that people can find what they need without a treasure map. This is where colocation – or putting similar things together – comes into play. It's a simple idea, but it can make a huge difference in how we manage our shelves and help our library users find their way around. Let's talk about how this approach can make our libraries more user-friendly and efficient. Why Colocation Matters  Imagine you're looking for a cookbook. You go to the section where cookbooks are supposed to be, but instead of finding them all in one spot, they're scattered all over. Some are with the gardening books, others are near the science fiction. Frustrating, right? That's the problem colocation solves. By keeping similar items together – all the cookbooks in one place, all the science fiction in another – we make life easier for everyone....

Weekly Facebook Reel Plan 008: Pretending to be Tourists for a Day

Creating a one-week reel plan around the theme "Pretending to be Tourists for a Day" sounds like a fun and engaging way to connect with your audience. Here's a table that outlines the plan: Day of the Week Concept Execution Monday Local Landmarks Visit local landmarks and take photos as if you're seeing them for the first time. Tuesday Food Tour Sample local cuisine from various eateries and discuss the flavors and textures. Wednesday Public Transport Adventure Ride the local public transport and show the experience, including buying tickets. Thursday Street Performers Find street performers and capture their acts, maybe even join in for a collaborative moment. Friday Souvenir Shopping Visit local souvenir shops and showcase unique items, discussing their cultural significance. Saturday Museum Hopping Go to a local museum and take photos of interesting exhibits, discussing their history. Sunday Scenic Spots Visit a local park or beach and capture the natural beauty, p...

What is Special About a Coming-of-age Novel?

A  coming-of-age novel  has distinct traits that set it apart from other genres, primarily through its focus on personal growth and self-discovery. Here’s what makes it unique:        1.     Focus on Character Development        -     Core Theme:     The central theme of a coming-of-age novel is personal transformation. The protagonist, usually a young person, matures through experiences, gaining insight into themselves and the world.    -     Compared to Other Genres:     While many genres focus on external conflicts (e.g., fantasy battles or mystery puzzles), the coming-of-age novel centers on   internal   conflicts—struggles with identity, morality, and self-understanding.        2.     Transition from Youth to Adulthood        -     Rite of Passage:...

I Mistakenly Thought Lisbeth Salander was a Coming-of-age Heroine

Lisbeth Salander from  The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo   can be seen as a heroine, but she’s not a traditional coming-of-age character. Instead, she embodies elements of personal evolution and self-discovery, though in a much darker and unconventional context.  Here’s why she fits, and why she doesn’t, into the coming-of-age mold.        Why She Fits: 1.     Self-Discovery and Growth    : Like a coming-of-age protagonist, Lisbeth grapples with understanding her own identity and place in the world. Her journey involves reclaiming control over her life and confronting the traumas of her past, similar to how coming-of-age stories often depict a young person learning about themselves. 2.     Emotional Evolution    : Lisbeth starts off as a loner, distrustful of nearly everyone, but over time, we see her form complex relationships, particularly with Mikael Blomkvist. Though not sentimental or soft, she gradu...

Simple Way to Ask Library Users to Rate the Library Service

  Library users do not always share their thoughts on how the librarian or school can improve their library service. In fact, some won't ever, unless prompted. Soliciting their thoughts using a suggestion box is also not as good a strategy as it is predicted to be. After all, the blank piece of paper near the suggestion box doesn't really guide the user. I also noticed that users would only use the suggestion box if they have a complaint, but not if they just want to go about their business and leave.  There must be a more pro-active way to solicit users' opinion.  A simple solution would be to offer a short survey to measure how successfully users were able to complete some common activities in the library. This assessment uses the Likert scale, which is typically a five, seven, or nine-point agreement scale used to measure respondents' agreement with various statements. For example, the scale can range from "very unsuccessful" to "very successful."...

Weekly Facebook Reel Plan 007: Itinerary Planning for a Dream Destination

Planning a dream destination is an exciting theme that many people can relate to. Here's a one-week reel plan focusing on "Itinerary Planning for a Dream Destination":   Day of the Week Concept Execution Monday Budgeting Discuss the estimated costs for the trip and show how to create a budget spreadsheet. Tuesday Flight and Accommodation Research and compare flight options, then demonstrate how to book the best deal. Wednesday Local Transportation Simulate using local transportation apps to plan how to get around the destination. Thursday Must-Visit Spots Show a map and mark the must-visit spots, explaining why each is a can't-miss. Friday Food and Dining Talk about local cuisine and draw up a list of restaurants and food stalls to visit. Saturday Activities and Experiences Take photos of different activities you'd like to do and create a visual day-by-day plan. Sunday Packing List Write down a packing list tailored to the destination and activities, then demonstr...

Flash Fiction: The Librarian's Halloween Hexes

Every Halloween, when dusk began to settle over Willowdale, Eleanor Marwick closed the public library with a smile that was as much mischief as it was politeness. By day, Eleanor was the quintessential librarian: quiet, precise, and draped in an earthy cardigan. But as October 31st arrived, she was, for one night, something else entirely. Tonight, as soon as the clock chimed seven, she shed her librarian guise and stepped into her true role: the witch of Willowdale. Her cardigan transformed into a flowing cloak, her sensible shoes became lace-up boots that clicked against the cobblestone paths. A grimoire appeared in her hands, pages filled with spells in looping ink, all waiting to be unleashed. The first stop was Mrs. Haversham’s house. Sweet, gray-haired Mrs. Haversham never missed a due date and handled every book with reverence. Eleanor whispered a soft incantation, and immediately Mrs. Haversham’s garden burst into a spectacle of flowers that would bloom all winter. Mrs. Haversha...

Short Story: Deliverance

Categories: FRIENDSHIP, DRAMA, CRIME It had been twenty-four years since she’d last seen it, but the place looked exactly the same. The boarded up windows gave the impression that the buildings lining the street were not habitable. Katie smiled and nodded at the curious eyes peeking out from the slats of wood as she passed them, knowing that her blonde hair, blue eyes, and fair complexion got the locals excited. This old motel strip in the seediest corner of Metro Manila, Philippines had been both a place to hide and recuperate, and the best venue for secrets. Why she went back was as much a mystery as it was a marvel. It was hard to imagine that after all the craziness that happened in the past, she would want to come back and look for… something. Perhaps it was closure that she was after.

Story Seeds Journal: Because Writing Inspiration Can Be Powerful But Fleeting

I have designed a Story Seeds Journal on Amazon, and you can see it via this link: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DJD1NCC1 What is this journal for? It can serve as a personal idea repository . It serves as a personal vault of story seeds, allowing writers to store and revisit ideas, which can be developed later into full projects. It increases story output . By encouraging the regular recording of new ideas, it can lead to a larger collection of potential stories to work from in the future. It builds writing confidence . Structured guidance helps writers see their ideas grow, building confidence in their ability to generate and develop stories.